Monday, February 17, 2014
Star Wars without The Lightsabers but add vampires.
I didn't actually see the connection until Boswell said it but I think it was a very interesting point. I am going to break down my answer just like you broke down the questions. The first point is the mandates. The mandates of the Dark Side in Star Wars is to rule the galaxy. The mandate of the Dark Others in Nightwatch was to get the boy to join the Dark others but once again it seems to come down to a control thing. The mandates of Light Others and the Jedis seem to be similar. Their goal is to keep power and to keep the evil forces at bay. Although a similitary is it seems both are about a boy who could make the decision whether to be with the good side or the bad side and it seems in both he chooses bad. The Jedis and Siths only fight eachother. They never have tea or drinks together. They just seem to fight. On the other hand there seems to be a lot of just hanging out with the Light and Dark others. For instance Anton lives next to a dark other and the Yoda and Palpatine of the film seem to just like to chill out and help each others causes. The Jedis and Siths both get their power from their respective side of the Force. The Others all get their powers from blood whether they be Dark or Light. The line is not clear between the Others because they have the same rulebook. Its not like the Jedis where they have a different code of honor. The Others all have one rule book and both sides break it from time to time like when Anton tried to kill his son. My final point is I think that it does add something because it strengthens the idea that good and evil are the same. Star Wars makes it sound like evil can influence the good but Nightwatch takes that a step further and says that they are the same thing.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think you make a good point about Jedi/Light Others both striving for balance rather than just "beating the other side." I also think it's important to note that Jedi and Sith derive power from the SAME Force, not their "respective sides," as you put it. The reason I bring this up is that the Force, much like blood in Night Watch, is a neutral reservoir of energy and does not affect each side's decision.
ReplyDeleteNice job summing up the main idea, though. I think your last three sentences hit the nail on the head.
Thanks Owen! Made my day
ReplyDeleteI don't follow your idea that Nightwatch suggests "good and evil are the same." This would imply that Anton wishing his girlfriend to suffer and killing her child from jealousy is just fine. Perhaps you meant that no one is wholly good or wholly evil. Isn't a key distinction that the Nightwatch wants to preserve the truce and the Daywatch wants it to end (although they don't want to be the ones to end it)?
ReplyDeleteI think an important thing to note about Star Wars is the fact that many of the sith were once good. The Sith Lord in the original series was once a Jedi, just the same as Darth Vader, General Grievous, and many others in Star Wars lore.
ReplyDeleteIn the world of the others, good and evil are at odds, but this world is not known to the general population
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete